Sunday, October 21, 2012

Issue #84 October 21, 2012- Politics, Schools and Hope



What This Is…
Issue #84- October 21, 2012
In this issue: Politics, Public Schools and Hope for the Future

MMSD now has a website for Spanish speaking families!!


Style Over Substance…
We are nearing the end of another heated election cycle (for those of us in Wisconsin it has been over a year of near-constant campaigning) and politicians everywhere are providing us with examples of "style over substance" as they trade one liners and air advertising aimed at convincing voters to "buy their product".  As a society we face many very difficult issues, issues that can't be summarized in a brief ad, speech or other campaign communication.  Unfortunately, those short, limited communications are what many citizens use as a basis for deciding what candidates and policies to support. 

The reality is that the solutions to our challenges and problems can't be generated by bumper sticker slogans that oversimplify a problem or vilify a particular stance on an issue.  By relying on the "packaging" of a candidate or party we ignore the substance of their positions on important issues.  It reminds me of my childhood (and embarrassingly, my adulthood as well) where I would buy a cereal for the prize in the box, not necessarily the cereal itself. 

The obvious danger to our society is that by voting on style, we put politicians in place who don't have the knowledge, ability, skills, and/or desire to work to find reasoned, moderate solutions to issues.  Our elected officials are often beholden to special interests, or products of a flawed system where they have been able to essentially purchase their office.  This is certainly not true of all politicians, but an alarming number of them do fall into this type of category. 

Voters in our nation are swept along in a mass wave that is generated by propaganda with little basis in fact.  Thus we see Russ Feingold's statesmanship replaced by Ron Johnson's demagoguery.  We also see people casting ballots based on incomplete information.  Scott Walker's call to balance the budget resonated with voters, would it have had the same support if he had proposed eliminating public employee's collective bargaining rights during the campaign?   

The policies that result from these elections mirror the elections themselves.  Candidates that are elected based on glitzy campaigns find themselves mired in a process that is far removed from the "glamour" that the campaign trail offered.  When done well, our democratic process is not a thing of beauty to most of us.  Meetings, compromise, debate, meetings, debate, communicating, discussion, compromise… the process of creating positive policy and legislation is a tedious one that offers few opportunities for publicity.  Yet, our politicians need their "moments of glory" so that they can get re-elected every election cycle.

Elected officials find themselves looking for issues and policies that will allow them to stand out and gain support among the electorate.  This isn't necessarily a bad thing, we want those who represent us to do just that, represent us.  We elect them to stand up for us and to protect our interests while shaping policy that will allow our entire society to prosper.  Unfortunately, along with the need for votes, our modern candidates need significant financial support to "package" their "product" for the next election.  This leaves them vulnerable to influence by wealthy donors who may not be interested in promoting socially just, or economically fair policies.  In the end, we lose the substantive debate that our society's current, and future issues deserve and get a "sugary treat" that can end in decay.               


Public Education- Policy vs. Reality…
Public education is an area that has been significantly damaged by the lack of informed debate and the poor policy decisions that result from "Bumper-sticker Politics".  Too many of the people making important decisions about public education have too little knowledge about education in general and our public schools specifically.  This has resulted in decades of poor policy and obviously has damaged our public education system. 

This damage has accelerated exponentially in the last couple of decades.  Legislation like No Child Left Behind and numerous other "Education" bills have created an atmosphere where real education reform is stunted and resources are drained from our public schools.  All while touting privatization and attempting to funnel public money to for-profit schools. 

The actions of GOP leaders like Governor Walker have expanded the attacks by attacking not only public education (record budget cuts), but also by directly attacking public educators (Act 10 and the effort to eliminate collective bargaining for public employees).  This combination seems to have awakened many public educators and their supporters in states like Wisconsin.  We are realizing that we are involved in a struggle that goes beyond contracts, wages and benefits.  The future of our public education system is in jeopardy if we continue on the paths mapped for us by those claiming to want to "reform" our schools. 

The false reformers rely on their ability to simplify a problem and to create what appears to be a "common-sense" solution that will gain popular support.  They create and publicize a "crisis" and use the public concern to take control of the debate surrounding education.  The GOP has been very effective in their efforts to set the tone of discussions about public education.  So effective that Democrats echo many of the sentiments that Republicans have initiated. 
      
 


The "reformers" have used a few basic arguments to attack public education and have been very effective in delivering their message.  I have no problem with the supporters of these "reforms" touting their ideas, nor do I have a desire to stifle debate that could lead to positive results for our public schools and the students they serve.  The proposing and advocating of ideas is a vital part of our democratic process.  Concepts and ideas like the Madison Prep proposal focus attention on issues and generate more involvement from all sides of an argument. 

However, there is a more sinister side to these discussions that appears all too frequently.  It is up to all of us involved to make sure that we don't allow a small number of individuals with specific interests to manipulate and control the debate.  


We are seeing discussion in Madison about a proposed change at Toki Middle School that could result in a charter school program replacing the existing, more traditional school model.  More discussion needs to occur in a positive way, but discussing changes allows for growth to occur.  As Frederick Douglass said, "If there is no struggle, there is no progress".  


My problem with education "reform" as it is currently presented in America is twofold.  First, I don't believe that a significant number of the "reforms" proposed are really designed to improve education.  Many of the proposals are simply efforts to funnel money to a new recipient, usually a private company or individual. 

My second major problem with education "reform" is the fact that policies based on simplifying issues or hyper-focusing on specific issues results in flawed policy.  If these policies were simply broad, generalized and relatively harmless that would be one thing, but instead these policies result in specific damage to schools and students.  Every piece of legislation or educational policy implemented has an impact on students or educators somewhere and we can't ignore the realities of the impacts that they have. 

A couple examples…

Accountability- We've been hearing it for some time, our schools are failing and we need to hold them accountable in order to compete with other nations in a global marketplace.  In order to know whether our students are succeeding or not we need to assess them.  We can use the data generated by these assessments to evaluate school districts, specific schools, programs and individual educators as well.  In addition there are key concepts that, if understood, will predict a student's ability to be successful in future activities.  That's what "reformers" would have us believe. 

It is true that assessment is a vital part of the educational process.  Assessments can be used to guide instruction and to determine a student's understanding of a subject or skill.  However, the best assessments are not single events based on a small number of responses on a standardized test.  Instead, a professional educator is able to assess a student in multiple formats on a number of occasions and monitors student progress over time. 

The results of the flawed "reform" policies are things like the upcoming DPI School Report Cards.  These evaluations focus on a small number of specific criteria and standardized testing.  The results will be released on Monday, October 22nd and I predict that turmoil, finger-pointing and confusion will result. 
         

You see, in order for a report card to be effective, everyone involved needs to understand what is being evaluated, how it is being evaluated and what the significance of the evaluation is.  None of these things is true with the school report cards and most people will simply look at the number and use that as a comparison of what schools are "good" and what schools are "bad".  Families will see a score and wonder what it is that they are missing when they think about the education their child is receiving. 

The report card is only the most recent, and most visible, example of the flawed policies involving schools and accountability.  I've written quite a lot about the problems with testing and other accountability measures.  The reality is that students lose valuable instruction time, educators find their curriculum limited to "testable" skills and topics and families are frustrated by the different numbers and results that are shared after assessments are given. 

If another example is needed, it comes from many Madison educators who are just finishing their initial rounds of required assessments.  Now they are ready to start teaching, but wait, November is "Standardized Test Month" here in Wisconsin.  This narrows many educators instructional time to a few weeks in October and early November sandwiched around 2 professional development days and Halloween.  No worries though, we will get back to instruction just in time for Thanksgiving, Winter Break and the assessments necessary to complete our end of semester report cards.  No wonder so many educators are frustrated.  Policy makers just don't understand what damage they've done to our students.    

Of course there are always those who resist these reforms.


School Finance Reform/The Schools as a Business Model- Reformers argue that our public schools are like "money sponges", just soaking up dollars and not releasing much of value.  They point to the test scores and rising costs of educating students and claim that it could be done more efficiently and more effectively if we just cut costs, trimmed staff, and ran our schools like businesses. 

The best example of this rhetoric, turned into policy should be obvious.  Scott Walker's budget trimmed the "fat" from public schools in Wisconsin to the tune of $1.85 Billion over two years.  In return for the loss of state aid, he gave local school boards "tools" to offset the cuts.  Act 10 and the changes in rules regarding collective bargaining for school district employees was supposed to make up the difference by having employees pick up more of their health care costs, pension contributions and eliminating the unions that supposedly cost the system so much money.

Here's a sampling of articles from the past week or so, showing just how successful this idea has been.    









Then there is the reality that if you combine high stakes testing with school financing you will get a business model.  Corners will be cut and changes made in order to insure success.  Unfortunately, we aren't talking about discontinuing a product line, or changing hours of business.  We are talking about someone's child.


As budgets are cut, students and families are also impacted as they look ahead to their college careers.  We are seeing a huge rise in student loan debt that is making a college education "unprofitable" for many Americans.  


Forming a Partnership Between Schools and Communities…
The current climate surrounding public education may be gloomy, but there is always hope.  An example of this occurred last week when a small group met at a local Madison restaurant to discuss public education and what can be done to defend it.  The group included a couple of educators and several community members who have students that attend Madison's public schools.  Discussion ranged from testing, to charter schools to curriculum and more. 

We talked for almost two hours and decided to meet again in the near future.  Each of us will try to bring a few more people in to the discussion group and we will look for topics that are of interest and importance.  We don't know where the group is headed and what will come from our meetings, but I have hope that it will be the beginning of a larger effort here in Madison to connect our schools and educators with the larger community. 

I am participating in a couple of other efforts to facilitate communication around issues involving public education and public educators.  These initial efforts to expand communication and to share information about what is happening to/in our public schools gives me optimism for the future.  I hear from other educators about their efforts to connect with the communities they serve and my "Hope-Meter" jumps more in the positive direction. 

As Ralph Ellison said, "Education is all a matter of building bridges."  Along the same lines, Isaac Newton stated, "We build too many walls and not enough bridges."  The survival of public education depends on the number of walls we knock down and the number of bridges we build.  The time to start construction is now.       

Sunday, October 14, 2012

Issue #83 October 14, 2012- Problems with elections, Charter schools and Walmart



What This Is…
Issue #83- October 14, 2012
In this issue: Democracy at Risk, Charter School in Madison?, Support Walmart Workers

A Crisis For Our Democracy…
We live in a time period when everything that happens seems to be a crisis, the most important…, or some grave threat to our way of life.  Of course there are some recent events that are historical in their proportions, but with the constant blaring of 24/7 TV and radio shows, combined with the instant commentary on the internet, it is often difficult to see the real significance of any event/policy/individual.  The competition to be the first to cover a story or to offer some different analysis means that we are flooded with constant hype and rhetoric.

Having said that, it appears that we are at a definite crisis point in our nation's electoral process.  America is a remarkable nation when it comes to the election of new officials and the transferring of power.  We have developed an elaborate system for electing our leaders and (even though many of us don't bother to vote) for the most part Americans have supported and trusted this process.  Our democratic traditions have allowed us to endure significant turmoil and heated debate, while avoiding widespread bloodshed and civil unrest.  A case may be made that there are other, perhaps more sinister, forces that play a role in this as well, but in the end we have developed a relatively peaceful way of putting new leaders in power.  This is especially true when you look at other places around the world and the conflicts that erupt as power is transferred or seized.

Like all human creations, our electoral system has a checkered past and a few inherent flaws.  We've excluded entire groups from participating and witnessed significant corruption during our nation's history.  The system isn't perfect, but at the same time is a process that we can work with and that allows for citizens to voice their opinion in a positive and potentially meaningful way. 

Like most aspects of our nation's government and political structure, the electoral process has seen its share of successes as well as challenges.  What makes our current situation such a crisis in our political development?

Trust in the System- As I mentioned before, our electoral system has never been free of corruption and/or scandal.  If we admit that power has a potentially corrupting influence, then it is logical that at least some of those interested in achieving powerful positions will be corrupt as well.  We've all read about the scandals that have happened in our history and comments about things like "Chicago Politics" or "Political Bosses" aren't met with surprise.  We all recognize that there are individuals and groups that will do just about anything to gain, and hold on to power. 

What makes the current erosion of trust in our electoral system potentially disastrous is that it isn't the candidates involved who are being questioned (that's an important part of the process), it's the system itself and the results of our elections that are under fire.  Conservatives have made it a point to question the validity of elections because of the "rampant voter fraud" that they claim exists (but have little evidence for).  Their solution…voter ID and other restrictions on voting rights.  
    
 

 

Liberals and progressives find flaws on the other end of the voting path, the counting of ballots.  There are significant concerns about the accuracy of the vote tallies as well as the ability to alter the voting totals by "hacking" the machines.  These concerns have been visibly demonstrated in numerous elections recently. 



Whatever the issues about our electoral system may be, the concern is that we are headed down a path where the results of our elections are not viewed as legitimate.  Without meaningful elections is it possible for us to claim we have a democracy here in America?  We need to restore the faith that people have in the process or risk undermining the foundation of our political system. 

Participation in the System- At the same time we are facing a crisis in confidence in our electoral system, we also face the ongoing reality that many Americans are simply not participating in the process.  What is considered a good turnout on election day is often less than half of the potential voters.  This obviously results in skewed election results that favor a mobilized base that consistently votes, while the majority of the citizens of our nation simply accept the results as they occur.  Even in "high turnout" elections we don't get the participation that our democracy needs to be a true representation of the general public. 

The results of this voter apathy are skewed results that represent a minority of the population.  We also see our elected officials losing their accountability to the people they are supposed to be representing.  If most people don't vote, then those elected only need to represent the interests of a small, well connected few.  The long term effects of this are clear as our leaders become more insulated from their constituents and more susceptible to the influence of their donors and vocal supporters. 

There are many reasons that people don't participate in the current system, but as a nation we need to change this pattern in order to regain control of a system that is currently governed by special interests.  Recent efforts have been made to limit participation in the electoral process, but we have also seen actions designed to encourage voters to become informed and involved.  



Another huge problem is the lack of knowledge that many citizens have in how our government works and what the candidates who are running stand for.  The electorate is divided between those who are firmly entrenched in opposite camps.  At the same time there is a significant number of "independent", "undecided" voters who are drifting between candidates and who are susceptible to propaganda and the, often unreliable, information put out by candidates and the media. 

www.nbc.com

In order to have a working system we need our citizens to realize that it is their actions which have created the system we have.  A nation where people have the freedoms that we do will get the government it deserves and we, as voters, need to be accountable for the officials we elect.  It may take some extra time, but the results will be positive for all of us if each person becomes truly and accurately informed and gets involved.


Money and its Corrupting Influence- We can't ignore the impact that big money has on our political system.  Citizens United has changed the political landscape and made our system one that is ripe for purchase by the highest bidder.  This doesn't change the fact that we still elect our leaders and representatives and as citizens need to actively seek out accurate information and recognize what our candidates stand for.  Money is only one of the reasons our system is declining and we need to stop using it as an excuse.  There are many candidates and activists working to counter the influence that large donations have and we should be working to support their efforts. 

Confidence in our Candidates and Political Parties- With all the negative advertising, conflicting information and mudslinging in politics today, it is no wonder that many Americans are disgusted and fed up with politics.  Almost all parties and candidates seem to have changed their campaign strategies away from promoting themselves to attacking their opponent.  This means that we potentially lose our ability to make a choice between ideas and instead vote out of fear or hatred.  Too many voters see their choices as an opportunity to vote for the lesser of two evils.       

Media Coverage and Lack of Accurate Information- Our major media outlets often seem more like gossip magazines and are more focused on small relatively petty issues or surface data than they are on the underlying realities that shape candidates platforms or policies.  In depth, investigative reporting based on facts doesn't seem to get the attention that opinion driven, shallow stories garner.  Whatever the reason, our media outlets have limited their coverage to sound bites and short pieces that repeat information that is given to them by political parties, candidates or special interests.  Anyone who is directly involved in an ongoing story being covered by the news immediately recognizes the differences between the reality experienced and the "reality" reported.

What Do We Do?- All of these problems add up to a significant problem in our electoral system.  The only real answer is for the people of America to decide that they are not going to be manipulated any more.  People of all political beliefs must recognize that it is only a small minority of citizens who are benefiting from the current trends in the system.  The good of the many is not being served by the direction our nation is heading.  If we are going to get the government we truly deserve we must be willing to fight for it. 

Our fight starts by finding accurate sources of information, challenging ourselves to listen to other viewpoints and being an informed voter.  We need to be able to discuss politics with others who may not agree with us.  We must communicate our concerns to our elected representatives in articulate and persuasive ways.  We also must be willing to organize and exert our collective influence when necessary.  The statement "United We Stand, Divided We Fall" has never been more true.       

New Madison Charter School?…
I don't know enough about the situation to make any real commentary about it, but the Madison Board of Education is meeting on Monday 10/15 to discuss making changes in the programming at Toki Middle School.  These changes could result in the school becoming a charter school.  This is a development that is of obvious concern to all of us who fear the potential for privatization of our public schools, and bears careful watching and monitoring.      


Stand With Walmart Workers…
No single company is more representative of the current conflict between corporations, their employees and the well being of our nation than Walmart.  Most of Walmart's employees don't make a living wage and they frequently require public assistance to supplement their low wages.  The company pulls in huge amounts of money, and at the same time benefits from negotiated tax breaks.  Companies that supply products to Walmart are pressured to produce more at a lower cost, thus harming workers at other companies.  Walmart eliminates competitors and drives local businesses out of the market.  Yet, there are those who would hold up Walmart as an example of the "American Free Market" and the success it can bring (to a small number at the expense of many).    
Walmart workers are starting to organize and fight back.  These workers need our support.
   

Sunday, October 7, 2012

Issue #82 October 7, 2012- Testing and New Contracts



What This Is…
Issue #82- October 7, 2012
In this issue: Standardized Testing, MMSD Educators Under Fire

Testing, "Mapping" a Road to Nowhere…
Assessment is a vital part of the educational process.  Educators need to know what their students know and we use assessment to guide our instruction as well as inform us about student progress.  Parents and other adults in students lives want to know where their child stands in their educational development.  Educators share information gathered from assessments, student work and other observations with families in an ongoing effort to support student learning of important skills and information. 

Unfortunately, assessment has become a "tool" used for an entirely different purpose.  So called, "reformers", want to assess children in order to rank and evaluate educators and schools, not to make education better, but to somehow document our success or failure in educating young people.  In doing so, they've turned education into a form of competition where we can identify schools that are successful by their numerical rank or by some other formula based on data collected by standardized testing. 

We have an epidemic of testing that has broken out in our nation's schools and it is deadly to learning and student achievement.  I could spend some more time looking at this issue from a "big picture" perspective, but there is another reality that is much more important than the political or sociological one.  That reality is the one that I work in on a daily basis.  It is populated by a cadre of dedicated educators and caring families.  The primary inhabitants, in fact the ones for which this environment is created for, are the students who come each day to work and learn in my classroom (and in classrooms around our city, state and nation).

We can debate issues and policy forever and never come to a satisfactory conclusion that will please everyone.  However, on an individual basis in classrooms everywhere the success or failure of our public schools is easier to define.  Every year I sit down with families and students and we identify needs and goals for the year.  Over the course of the year there is constant assessment, evaluation and a flow of communication between home and school about the students I serve.  All of us work together to try and find the best ways to make sure that students are learning necessary skills and information that they will need in the future. 

In many cases this isn't a smooth or easy process.  Growth is rarely linear and constant, but the important thing is the collective effort and cooperation between home, school and the community.  We may agree or disagree about the methods we use to educate any given student, but in the end it is the student whose needs take the highest priority.  We try different ideas and utilize different resources, all while maintaining the focus on the child.

This is true for a majority of the school year, but there are too many times where this cooperative effort is disrupted and undermined by the intrusion of mandates from outside sources.  Sometimes these interruptions are simple, isolated problems that are resolved quickly, but there are also some that are symptomatic of a larger pattern that is emerging in our public education system. 

An example of these types of disruptions are the changes implemented for elementary school educators Monday afternoon planning time by MMSD administration.  By taking time that had been available for educators to use independently and using a significant amount of that time for formal professional development or other meetings we lost time to communicate with families and other educators.  In the last round of contract negotiations our district's administration offered the idea of changing staff hours and making us have planning time in the morning, before school.  That is another time when many educators are able to communicate with the families of their students.       

Educators in Madison have fought to try and preserve as much of our previous schedules as possible, and to some degree have been successful.  However, there is another, more disruptive, intrusion into our time with students and our communication with families…standardized testing.  This testing takes up a significant amount of instructional time, undermines student's efforts and results in misleading information that confuses and frustrates families.

How much time is significant?  I knew we spent a lot of time testing, but recently was asked exactly how much and added up the hours.  Between the three MAP sessions, the WKCE, the COGAT and additional testing required by MMSD to meet guidelines imposed by legislation and education policy the number is too high.  You can't forget the amount of time spent preparing for testing in this number as well.  The result?  Specific numbers vary by grade level, but the amount of time used for standardized assessment is extensive.     

More time must also be considered lost as schedules are altered to accommodate testing as well.  Students at this grade level don't just test and then switch to another topic without needing time to recover.  We also want to make sure that they are performing their best so we change our curriculum during these testing periods and reduce their workload.  This results in more lost instructional time for students at all elementary grade levels.  Because different grade levels have different testing requirements and many Madison classrooms have combined grades this adds to the disruptive effects of testing.   

The time lost becomes more significant at lower grades where students are not capable of taking individualized standardized tests and therefore must be tested individually by trained professionals, usually teachers.  The result is that these students who are most in need of instruction lose the learning time with their teacher in exchange for assessment time.    

In many school buildings a tremendous amount of effort is put into attempting to minimize the impact that testing has.  The results are a cobbled together, "best of a bad situation" solution.  What is missing from the current discussion in most schools is not, "How do we make this work" but instead should be, "Why are we contorting our schedules and disrupting our student's educations for these assessments?"  As soon as we move the focus of our discussion away from asking whether our assessments are useful and good for students we lose the true meaning of education and assessment.  We become proxy advocates for testing by adapting our curriculum and schedules to fit the tests not the students. 
 
The assessments affect individual students in different ways, but the results are rarely positive.  Educators are under pressure to administer these tests and often the testing environment is quite different from the daily classroom environment.  In most Madison classrooms students are encouraged to ask questions, challenge ideas and work cooperatively to learn about any given topic.  Standardized testing is an entirely different situation and many of our students struggle to adapt, even with significant test preparation instruction.

In fact standardized testing creates a negative atmosphere and reduces each student to a number, or box to be filled in.  Exactly the type of situation that we are trying to avoid as we work to engage and motivate our highest risk students.  Because we can't leave any child "behind" we must force students who already have fragile and tenuous connections to school to sit isolated and prove that they are struggling academically.  I won't mention specifics (to protect student anonymity) but I have seen testing negatively impact many students in my years of teaching, and the effects are increasing as the testing becomes more intense and more value is placed on the scores.  Watching students take a standardized test and seeing their heads drop, the tears flow and their frustration build hurts me as an educator. 

Standardized testing forgets that these are children who have a very different idea of what they are doing during the testing than the adults who create the tests do.  I have many examples of this that I have seen during my 15+ years as an educator.  In fact my own experience with standardized testing offers an insight into why we need to take all testing results with a "grain of salt".  I have always tested well, usually scoring quite high, but I remember my mindset wasn't optimal during testing.  As a big baseball fan (and unfortunately for me a Cubs supporter) the A/B/C/D/E choices became the Astros, Braves, Cubs, Dodgers and Expos.  Naturally my default answer was "C", Cubs. 

I've heard my own students talk about their thoughts during testing and the discussions don't increase my faith in the test results.  A recent student said their favorite part of the MAP testing (done on the computer) was "clicking" (believe it or not, this student needed repeated interventions to stay focused during testing).  I've heard many teachers talk about their difficulties in getting students to perform their best on tests that mean little to them personally.  The lack of direct connection to topics we are working on, the seemingly random nature of the questions and the disruptions to school routines all contribute to student's disconnect with the tests.    

We often seem to forget that we are taking students who are young and just developing their skills and shaping their ideas about education.  For the majority of the school year we work closely with them and encourage their progress.  Then during these testing sessions we change our interactions, enforce a whole new strict set of rules and emphasize their performance in different ways.  This makes students feel uneasy and magnifies the importance of the tests in their minds.  It certainly doesn't help that those students who stay up on current events see the importance that adults outside of their school experience place on the test results either. 

The reporting of results provides another set of variables that decreases the usefulness of standardized tests.  It is difficult to convey to families and students what their scores mean.  After students finish their MAP test, their score appears on the final screen.  As we leave the computer lab I find myself besieged by students clamoring to know what a 214, 201, 197, etc. means.  Of course their WKCE scores have an entirely different scale, and other assessments also use different values to measure scores.  As educators we are placed in the position of translating numbers to families when we really should be talking about other aspects their child's education.

The way the test results are used is also troubling.  I have had students who were struggling in significant ways denied access to additional support or Special Education evaluations because their test scores were not low enough.  At the same time I have seen students offered or excluded from TAG recommendations based on these scores.  These things happen even when multiple educators and student's families speak up and advocate for students needs.  The test score becomes the most valued data about a student, while those who know the child best and who have professional experience are left trying to justify their opinions that have been formed by observing the student on a daily basis. 

As an educator I have no problem with accountability.  I expect the most from myself and my students.  I want feedback and constructive opinions from families and welcome evaluations from my administrators.  Accountability isn't the issue here, the real issue is that I want to be held accountable for the right things.  I want my students to be able to lead happy, productive lives and to have an educational background that will support their efforts.  That is what I work towards, not higher test scores that measure vague, ambiguous skills whose value is determined by some source far removed from the lives of my students and their families.    

In the end, the test scores become another way to divide people who attend, support and work in public schools.  Programs and educators are evaluated on the merits of their ability to improve a student's test taking ability while ignoring the fact that these tests are only on measure of student progress.  We have huge issues with equality of opportunity in our society and our educational system reflects the disparity between the "haves" and the "have-nots". 

Testing our students won't eliminate the Achievement Gaps, but it certainly provides ammunition for those who would radically change our educational system.  Standardized tests can provide some useful data, but shouldn't be employed at the expense of other forms of assessment that will help improve the instruction that students receive.  Until educators, students and families unite to challenge the dogma that standardized testing is a valid and valued way to evaluate our schools and students we will find ourselves continuing down a path that leads to educational ruin.             









Madison Educators, Between a Rock and a Hard Place…
It's difficult to know how to react to the recent negotiations and ratification of contracts for all MTI bargaining units and the AFSCME units who work in MMSD.  On one hand there is relief that we were able to get a contract that protects us through 2014.  On the other hand is the bitter taste left after seeing what the future of public educators in Madison will look like unless we are able to change the existing climate that surrounds our schools.

There is no doubt in my mind that we didn't receive the respect or the contract that we deserve.  I know that conservatives would agree with this statement, but for different (less friendly) reasons.  The contracts that were negotiated leave Madison educators still well off when compared to other school districts or public employee unions in other parts of Wisconsin.  Our negotiating teams were able to preserve many parts of our collective bargaining agreement and even were able to remove the threat of wage reductions for our hard hit hourly employees.  





The protection of a contract for another year gives us more time to work on building support for our efforts to protect public education and more time to work to educate the general public about what is happening in education "reform" movements.  We have an obligation to define our positions regarding education reform and to take the lead in creating an atmosphere that allows for change, while still protecting educators and public education.  It allows educators in Madison a reprieve from the immediate threats of a handbook and the challenges that new policies would bring to our daily labors with students.    

That this was accomplished while we were backed against a wall and had a short negotiating window with little leverage to bargain with is truly remarkable.  It is also a testimony to the support that Madison educators enjoy from the public and from some of the School Board and parts of our administration.  We shouldn't forget that the district didn't have to bargain, but could have waited for the legal challenges to be decided.  Their refusal to consider some of MTI's proposals or to budge on some of their demands showed the disparity in power that exists in current labor/management relations. 

While it would be wonderful if district administration and the educators they employ could work together, it is clear that there are different agendas which make cooperation difficult.  This is extremely unfortunate.  Now is the time when all those involved in public education from the top administrator down should be finding common ground and not fragmenting in the face of the attacks by "reformers".      

There are several troubling things about this current round of negotiations. 
Bargaining with employees should be a reasonable expectation and not considered an act of generosity.  The concept that we were lucky to even get a chance to negotiate a new contract shows just how distorted things have become in Wisconsin. 

Many of the MMSD proposals read like a blueprint that would be supported by educational "reformers" who look to privatize public education.  As it ended, there is still the potential to change the way our schools operate under this new contract.  The antipathy that developed during the Madison Prep debate appeared during the negotiations as MTI was portrayed as an obstacle to student achievement by some MMSD negotiators.

Under current labor conditions it is very difficult to adapt existing contracts to new or different ideas.  In the past contracts could be altered by both parties agreeing to do so and creating formal "amendments" to the contracts.  Now, under Act 10, unions and school districts have lost that flexibility.  Who knows what MTI and MMSD would be able to do if real bargaining could be done. 

The educators who make up MTI are committed to improving student achievement and it is insulting to assume that we aren't.  We are also committed to making sure that educators are treated fairly and that working conditions are reasonable for all educators.  This can sometimes cause difficulties as new programs are implemented, but often results in good dialog that makes for stronger proposals in the long run.  

It is clear that there are those in MMSD who would like to see MTI disappear and be given complete freedom to control the employees in the district.  Some of the sticking points in negotiations showed this to be very true.  For example, all MTI represented employees could pay up to 10% of their health insurance premiums under the new contract.  Teachers, the largest number of MTI members, offered to pick up the entire cost of any insurance premium increases for the other units.  These units have been the most impacted by recent reductions in take-home pay.  However, MMSD refused this, even though it didn't affect student achievement and would not have impacted the district's budget.

The initial proposals offered by the district were a terrifying look into what an employee handbook might look like in the future.  The proposals take us in a direction that leads towards privatization and the struggles that other urban school districts have already encountered.  It is clear that public education in Madison is facing dire threats to its survival. 

Public education needs to be just that, public, and part of this public nature of things is the participation of groups representing all concerned parties.  In the case of public education this means that input from many sources, including educators, needs to be heard.  We can't run our public schools like a business and ignore the concerns of the professionals who staff our schools.  The process that existed prior to Act 10 may not have been perfect, but it allowed multiple perspectives to be heard when issues were bargained.  I hope that future discussions will keep this in mind and that we don't allow any single group to dominate the conversations as we work to improve our schools for all students.

As educators we need to keep this in mind as we work to build connections with the communities we serve.  In some cases MTI is seen as an impediment to progress and we must make it clear that our concerns are presented in ways that reinforce our commitment to making schools good places for everyone to work and learn.       

It is said that in every cloud is a silver lining and that is how educators here must approach the negotiation and ratification of our contracts.  Our negotiating teams and MTI staff won us another year to continue the fight to protect public education and to preserve our labor rights.  Madison has often been a leader in both of these fights and we have the opportunity to be in the forefront again. 

We must use this extra time to build support within the community and to share our message with the general public.  It is distressing that so few in the community know about or understand the importance of public education.  We need to build connections with all parts of the Madison community and develop working relationships with the people who live, work and raise children in this city.  We have to listen to them, recognize their needs and work to build a school district that serves all parts of the population effectively.

We need to clarify our positions and demonstrate the willingness to work with different groups while still protecting the things that we value.  The issues around Madison Prep provide an example of how different organizations that want the same thing can come into conflict.  By clearly articulating our points of view and connecting with other groups, compromises and discussion can occur.  If all parties operate in good faith, with the interests of the students as the primary focus, then positive results will occur. 

Of course all actions have consequences and we can't sacrifice future generations of students by gutting our public education systems in the present.  We have seen how privatization has negatively impacted schools in communities across the nation.  The "tool" used by supporters of privatization has been the need to address a "crisis" in public education.  We should be wary of these quick fixes and look towards building sustainable reforms that are focused on the good of the most students possible.       

MTI's membership must also work to develop solidarity and strength.  Too many of us have been content to let a small number represent our interests.  We are all ambassadors for our union and for public education.  We also can't forget that the things we are losing took years and significant struggle to gain and concessions now mean a repeat of these battles.  We have time, it may be "borrowed", but we do have the opportunity to build an even stronger organization to represent public education and public educators in Madison.  Our efforts will provide support and motivation for other educators around the state, just like the Chicago teachers inspired us. 

We may be tired, we may be angry, we may be disheartened, we may be all that and more.  However, at the same time we are educators and we are proud of our profession, our schools and our union.  The solidarity exhibited during negotiations spread through all MTI and AFSCME units.  Now we need to work on strengthening the bonds that unite us while spreading our solidarity to our community.  Each of us owes our best effort to each other and to our students.