Sunday, December 15, 2013

#143 December 15, 2013 Reality Check



Impending Doom, A Manufactured Reality. . .
We live in a time when everything seems to be a crisis and a matter of utmost importance.  The nature of our modern media coverage creates this atmosphere as different sources compete for consumer attention, advertisers and profits.  This climate extends from the media throughout our daily lives, but especially into the world of politics. 

The continual sense of crisis has turned politics into a battleground with clear divisions between viewpoints that often seem to be insurmountable barriers.  We become entrenched in our viewpoints and respond, not in thoughtful and reasoned ways, but in a knee-jerk reactionary mode of thinking.  Whatever the issue, it is inevitable that there will be an outpouring of opinions from all sides, and the most extreme will get the most attention. 
  
  

We seem to have lost sight of what politics and government should be about.  We've turned the process of governing our society into a strange combination of reality TV, sports and war.  Along the way the emphasis has become, not to serve the citizens represented by the government, but to win a contest that few understand and even fewer benefit from.  In fact, it seems like there is a real movement in politics to not only fail to serve, but to actually do harm to those who are not big money donors or who are not well represented by powerful lobbyists.     

In this climate of continual crisis, it is often difficult to get a real sense of what is truly important.  We've heard "Wolf" cried so many times that we become numb to the constant clamor that tells us the end of our democracy, the end of the American way of life, and many other "ends" are at our doorsteps.  Living in this highly emotionally charged atmosphere puts a constant strain on each individual's ability to process information and make decisions.  We know that pressure, stress and a sense of crisis changes the way that we look at the world, and influences many aspects of our lives. 

The evidence of the toll that this takes on all of us is clearly visible in the current political, social and economic conditions here in Wisconsin and across the nation.  An important question to consider is, who profits from the ongoing conflicts and sense of crisis? 

Remember that the reason people form into groups is to meet our basic needs in a world that can be very dangerous when we face it alone.  Human history has been a constant struggle to develop societies that address our needs as individuals while also allowing for us to work as cohesively as possible with others.  Our biggest advantage in the natural world is our ability to think, communicate and work together to overcome our challenges.  In order to reap the benefits of these skills we surrender some of our independence to the groups that we join.  However, there must always be some benefit for us to continue as a member, or else there must be some force that makes us continue our association with any larger group of people.

Most of us don't even consider this as we move through our daily lives.  We've gone past the point where we see being a citizen as a choice.  Instead, we accept that things are the way they are without considering that there could be other ways of organizing our communities or interacting with other groups.  We tend not to question things too much, and instead rely on others to make the decisions that shape the realities that we live in. 

To some extent this isn't a terrible thing.  After all, if everyone constantly questioned everything and tried to follow their own rules and norms, chaos would ensue.  Our nation has developed an elaborate set of rules that govern our interactions in all areas, and we have surrendered a significant amount of authority to those who we choose to represent us through political elections, financial decisions, and many other ways.  We trust that these individuals and processes will work fairly, and that they will produce satisfactory outcomes for most of us, and in many ways they do work for the most part.  Life in America is significantly better than in much of the rest of the world in terms of stability, safety and material goods.

Yet, at the same time this tendency to follow the guidance of those in positions of authority can be a negative trait as well.  We may need to follow rules, procedures and laws in order to enjoy the benefits of our society, but we should always be thoughtful about who we follow, what we follow, and why we follow.  There will always be positives about any society, but there will also be challenges that need to be addressed.  Blindly following any doctrine, leader or ideological philosophy opens the doorway to exploitation and manipulation that undermines the social contract that we all have entered in to. 

We stand at a crossroads in American history.  It is a crossroads that we have been at before, and that we will ultimately face many times in our future.  Each time the battles are slightly different.  This is true because the issues change, the individuals change and our society is never exactly the same as it was.  Yet, the conflict over who makes the social, political and economic decisions in our nation is a common theme.  Whether it is the struggle for equity that different groups have fought over the years, the struggle for economic justice, or any other issue, the core battle continues to revolve around where the center of power lies. 

Modern American society presents an interesting environment for this ongoing conflict.  We have a population that has access to information at a level never before seen in human history.  We have access to educational opportunities and historical knowledge which allows us to put our current struggles in perspective.  Our ability to communicate with others around our nation and our world is unprecedented. 

Yet, even with all of this potential, many of us are unaware of the depth of the struggles until someone points them out to us.  We find ourselves manipulated by those who would seek to maintain their control of power and wealth in our society.  We fail to exercise our rights and utilize the wealth of information available to us.  We see our world controlled in ways that we may feel are unfair or illogical, yet too often "sweat the small stuff" or allow our focus to be directed in ways that don't promote our own interests. 


Once again questions are raised, who profits from the different crises that are the focus of so much discussion in our society?  Are we focusing on the issues that really matter?  Are we following leaders who share our goals?  How can we best work to resolve the ongoing conflicts that exist in our society? 

One problem is that many of us tend to ignore political and economic issues until they directly impact our lives.  By the time we realize what is happening, it may be too late to halt the processes.  The election of Scott Walker and the passage of Act 10 provide us with an example of this.  A significant portion of the electorate didn't vote in 2010, and as a result took to the streets in 2011.  Had those voters turned out in 2010 we may have seen a totally different situation in Wisconsin. 

Of course it would help if politicians were honest about their plans and objectives when on the campaign trail, and after they are elected.  Because so many citizens don't keep up on issues they are vulnerable to leaders and messages that are extremely biased and misleading.  As a society we tend to put a lot of faith in our elected leaders even though we claim to mistrust government.  It is interesting that many who question the ability of our government to provide basic services and protections turn to leaders like Walker for the very things that they claim government can't provide.   
             

This crusade against unions, especially those representing public educators, is another example of the inconsistencies and questionable motives that drive the agenda.  We are told that unions are bad, that they are anti-American, and that the workforce is better off without them, yet without some representation workers are left vulnerable to all sorts of abuses.  This reality is borne out historically, and we are moving in the direction of repeating our past mistakes.   These mistakes are being made in all industries and in both public and private sector employment.    




In doing so we ignore the vast potential that a workforce united with management has.


The economic philosophies and policies that Conservatives offer are also geared towards benefitting a minority of the population.  At the same time they are preaching austerity and shrinking government, our Republican leaders are borrowing funds at a rapid pace and using the money to cover their flawed policies.   

Democrats refuse to take the GOP on and articulate a different way of doing business in Wisconsin and across America.  Instead, they use similar language and try to play the game by the Conservative's rules.  




Do we face a crisis here in Wisconsin?  The answer is yes, but it isn't the crisis that so many of our elected leaders and their mouthpieces would have us believe.  If we continue to believe the anti-labor, austerity rhetoric we will end up facing a truly substantial crisis that will impact all of us in significant ways.

Until we see leaders rise to the challenge and provide alternative ways to look at the challenges we face we will see the same solutions applied, and the same cycles repeat.  Instead of hiding behind the easy to defend rhetoric of low taxes, individualism and empty promises of freedom (while binding us to lives of debt and wage slavery), we need leaders who will lay out the facts and guide us in new directions.   It is up to the citizens to make sure that we get a government that truly represents the interests of the people.  The only way these leaders emerge is if the people reject the messages that we are currently being fed and support a different vision for our society.   

Assessment, Fueling a
Crisis in Public Education. . .
Our public schools are certainly not immune to the efforts to mislead the public and control the dialog around efforts to educate our youth.  The "reforms" that are being offered follow the same thinking as the mistaken philosophies in our political and economic spheres.  We are constantly being told that our public schools are "failing" and that we face a crisis of epidemic proportions unless drastic measures are taken. 

The catalyst for the crisis is assessment data.  Our public school students are tested, retested, evaluated and assessed endlessly.  Whether it is standardized tests mandated from the federal or state level, district mandated assessments, or the evaluations conducted by individual educators, our students are undergoing constant scrutiny regarding their progress in a wide range of areas. 

No educator will argue that assessing students isn't an important part of the educational process, we all rely on assessments to help guide our instruction and to understand the needs of our students.  Yet, the use of data in our schools has become an epidemic that threatens to drown out creativity and even threatens necessary instruction for students.  It is often our most at-risk students who are assessed the most, thereby missing valuable instructional time that they need to catch up with their grade-level peers.  Educators find themselves forced to conform to a specific way of teaching, or to specific topics, in order to insure that their students meet expectations on standardized assessments. 

Yet, we know that many of our assessments aren't producing valid and/or meaningful results.  We administer some assessments simply because it is a requirement of our job, not because it is good for our students.  Educators, family members and students question the assessments, but often meet resistance from those outside the classroom.  We then see the results of these tests used against us, and any complaints from educators is seen as "sour grapes" or a defense of our inability to educate students effectively. 

www.bbc.co.uk
        
The same questions that we can ask in the political and economic realms also apply in public education.  When we inquire about who benefits from the rash of assessments infecting our schools the answer seems obvious. 

"Last month, global consulting business McKinsey & Co. published a report concluding that the market for data in education from both public and private sources represented a new business venture worth between $900 billion and $1.2 trillion in annual economic value worldwide, about a third of it in the United States."

Educators have the same responsibilities that voters have when it comes to countering the flawed messaging of the "reformers".  We need to make sure that we consider the source of any information presented to us, question policies and programs appropriately and be strong advocates for our students.  There are many companies who are making huge profits by infiltrating our schools and providing "services" to schools, all so that they can reap the financial benefits. 
 

Human Friendly Shopping. . .
Many people I know have commented on how difficult it is to spend money in ways that don't leave them feeling guilty about giving their financial support to companies that either exploit workers, harm the environment, support ideologies that are in opposition to their beliefs, or any combination of these.  While that is very true, it is also important to remember that every penny spent at a more "friendly" establishment helps.  Keep trying to find places that sell products and promote Progressive ideas.     

7 simple tips for guilt-free holiday shopping: http://mojo.ly/1d4OBnj

Find more great made in Wisconsin products at http://buywi.org/

Sunday, December 8, 2013

#142 December 8, 2013- A Call to Action, "Good" vs. "Bad"



Thanks Marj. . .
The educational community in Madison experienced a significant loss this week when Marj Passman, long time public educator and advocate for our schools, announced that she wouldn't be seeking another term on the MMSD School Board.  While certainly not unexpected given her recent health concerns and the decades of devoted advocacy, there is no doubt but that her leaving the board will leave a void that will need to be filled.  She was a tireless advocate for public schools, students and educators.  She brought her experience from the classroom and her passion for teaching into the political and policy making fray, often giving voice to these groups that are too often ignored in our decision making processes.


It would be easy for me to continue on and give more examples of how important Marj has been to Madison's educational community and to my own family's experiences in public education.  When my wife was hired by MMSD she was privileged to work with a true "Dream Team" that included Marj, as well as several other educators who have gone on to fight for students, educators and public education at multiple levels.  As the years have gone by, Marj has always listened to what we've had to say, and then acted to incorporate our views while still maintaining her integrity.  She has endured criticism for her advocacy, but has never failed to keep the true purpose of public education at the forefront of her ideas and decisions. 


Yet, while she will be missed and should be thanked for her efforts, the reality is that the fight must continue.  I'm reminded of a quote about Dr. King that fits this situation as well.  Charles Willie, a classmate of King's at Morehouse, wrote, "By idolizing those whom we honor, we fail to realize that we could go and do likewise."  It isn't enough to thank Marj, the best thanks that we can give her is to step up and continue to advocate for our students, educators and our public schools.  That's exactly the role that educators fill, we supply the knowledge and the motivation to our students with the expectation that they will use what they've been given to make positive change happen in the world we live in.  Marj has provided us with a powerful role model and an example of how we can fight for what we value.  She has earned her opportunity to enjoy time with her family and a chance to relax, now it is up to us to follow her example. 

What's Best for Kids. . .
We spend a lot of time working to define what is "good" and "bad" in education.  The problem is that terms like "good" and "bad" really don't allow for much discussion to occur.  These words imply some sort of overarching truth that can be applied to our schools.  They ignore that fact that our schools are working to educate students who are diverse in many ways and who have different needs that must be addressed.  By dividing policies, practices and outcomes into mutually exclusive, quantifiable, and definable categories we create an atmosphere that stifles creativity, reduces learning and makes education a divisive battlefield instead of a source of unity and power.    



This isn't to say that there aren't things that are better for students, or that produce better outcomes for those attending our schools.  It also doesn't mean that we don't have goals that we want our students to achieve.  The problem is that when we categorize our efforts and seek to quantify the achievements of our students and schools, we limit the vision of what we can accomplish and force everyone involved in the effort into a narrow set of parameters that can only have a positive or negative impact.  We eliminate the grey areas in an endeavor that exists in a very grey reality.   


This emphasis on defining and measuring success has created a sense of crisis around education.  We search for ways to identify things that work for students, but we use faulty measures.  By doing so, we make the measuring tools the focus of our efforts, and fail to promote real learning.  We also implement programs and policies that, not surprisingly, end up being harmful to our students, educators and schools.    
    




Our nation's education crisis is really just a cover for the real issues which are the inequities in a system that favors those with wealth, and those of specific demographic categories.  The ways that we've engaged in debate around educational policy in America attempt to ignore these realities.  They place the blame for any failures of students to succeed on the educational system and educators, while ignoring the conditions that have a significant impact on student achievement.      


These factors have a major effect not only on students, but also on educators.  




What can be done in the face of such powerful forces that seek to control, manipulate and exploit our students and schools?  It takes the "whole village" to resist these privatization efforts and to put control of our schools in the hands of those who would use them to promote learning over profit.  



The goals of this day of action spell out a framework that can provide guidance in achieving our goals for public education. 
1) Revise how we fund public education.
2) Class size matters!  
3) Full professional staffing for all schools.  
4) A fully inclusive range of creative subjects.
5) The full funding for and inclusion of athletics, after-school programs, lunch, and recess.  
6) Course content and teaching methods emphasizing a diverse range of perspectives, needs, and voices that embody the diverse fabric of our society.  
7) Demand that curriculum be selected based on the needs of the community.  
8) Elimination of all high stakes standardized testing.  
9) Include meaningful systems for assessment and evaluation such as portfolios and project-based learning.  
10) Elimination of corporate interests in “funding” their right to promote their agenda for public education.  
11) Demand that your schools board be comprised of elected officials.  
12) Be informed about the “choice” policies coming to your district!  

Race in America. . .
We still have huge problems in America around issues involving race.  One of the most significant of these problems is the belief that is widely expressed that we don't have problems with race in America.  For many Americans racism ended when the visible barriers of segregation and Jim Crow were broken down by the Civil Rights Movement.  Now, it isn't uncommon to hear the problems of different racial groups blamed on the members of the groups or on other issues that are non-race related.
Yet, it is difficult to ignore the fact that while there are many issues that do impact an individual's experience in American society, race is one of the primary factors in determining how any individual experiences life in America.  It is a statistical reality that we must continue to work to address because it involves real people living life in a nation that is supposed to turn a blind eye to anything except an individual's abilities and merits.  The "content of our character" is supposed to mean more than the "color of our skin", but too often, for too many, that isn't the reality they live and work in.    
  


We must realize that, while it is possible to legislate some aspects of race relations, the majority of the work must be done on an individual, person to person, basis.  Here's a very powerful example of an effort that goes a long way towards combating racism where it is most effective. The following quotes sum up the best way to resolve any problem, and that also demonstrates the problems we face in America today.  Problems that stem from an unwillingness to discuss, and unwillingness to listen, and an unwillingness to admit that there's even a problem.    
"A lot of people have anti-racist groups. They get together and meet and have a diverse group and all they do and sit around and talk about how bad discrimination is. Then someone says ‘there’s a Klan group across town. Why don’t we invite them to come and talk to us?’ and the other person says ‘Oh no! We don’t want that guy here!’ Well, you’re doing the exact same thing they are. What’s the purpose of meeting with each other when we already agree? Find someone who disagrees and invite them to your table."
"Invite your enemy to talk. Give them a platform to talk because then they will reciprocate. Invite your enemies to sit down and join you. You never know; some small thing you say might give them food for thought, and you will learn from them. Establish dialogue. It’s when the talking stops that the ground becomes fertile for fighting."


Wisconsin Politics: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly. . .
The Good- It looks like we may have a primary to see who will represent the Democrats against Scott Walker.  The people of Wisconsin deserve to have a say in this important decision.   

“Every day I seem to be getting closer and closer to making the decision to run for governor because of the positive support I’ve found,” Vinehout told the Leader-Telegram.

Whatever the results of a primary election might be, the race would hopefully force the candidates involved to clearly articulate their positions on issues.  Without a challenge from another Democrat, Mary Burke can continue to simply be "Not Walker" in the race.  Her answers to questions and positions on the issues are too undefined and vague to generate significant support from those who could be persuaded to vote against Walker in 2014.

Statements like this one about the voucher program in Wisconsin leave me confused as to what exactly her position is, and what she would do to protect our public schools.   
"Well, I would look first and foremost in Milwaukee and Racine, where it already is, and you have 25,000 students in there. I think we have to look to quality of education above all else and I would work first toward that and the accountability. I don’t foresee any time in the near future that the Legislature will be able to work at anything else, and so that’s what I would certainly focus on, is making sure that the accountability is there now, and that would be a top priority."

Something we should be proud of, and something we need to continue to defend.


The Bad- Even though this loyalty oath never made it into official policy, the fact that it was suggested shows just how far ALEC would like to go towards completely controlling some of our elected officials.  


Our elected leaders continue to ignore what needs to be done and focus on gaining and maintaining power instead of promoting policies that will improve Wisconsin's economic outlook.  



Education is supposed to be a pathway to success, but for many it is also a pathway to debt and financial struggles.  



The Ugly- While Walker has tried to distance himself from this supposed "mistake", the inaccuracies and false claims continue to pour out as he prepares for future campaigns. 




Worker's Rights, Spend Your Money Wisely. . .
As we continue through the holiday shopping season it is too easy to forget the struggles for labor rights that are ongoing in our nation.  The gaps between the wealthy and the rest of America are continuing to expand, and the shopping/spending patterns that so many of us follow simply compound the problems.  


Support the efforts of employees who are fighting for better pay and better working conditions. 





Shop around and look for products made in America by union workers.  Also be sure to frequent shops that are based locally, that sell worker friendly products, and that support labor through their own policies.  

Sunday, December 1, 2013

#141 December 1, 2013- Failed Potential and Critical Thinking



What's Best for Kids. . .
America is a nation with virtually unlimited potential.  As a society we are able to accomplish great things and have a history of tremendous achievements in almost every aspect of human activity.  Yet, despite this potential and history of achievement, there are still some areas where widespread success has proved incredibly elusive.  One of the most significant of these is our inability to address issues of equality and opportunity for all citizens.  This failure has been a consistent feature of our society from the very beginning, but is has been magnified in recent years beginning with the "War on Poverty" and continuing to the huge disparity in wealth in current American society. 

These gaps in opportunity and achievement are clearly on display in our educational system.  We have a system that is one of the best in the world for some students, and one that struggles to match these successes for many others.  Our Achievement Gaps in schools, mirror the gaps that exist in our society in terms of income and access to power. 


For all of its flaws, one positive that No Child Left Behind accomplished was to shine a light on these gaps in our schools.  While it didn't come as a surprise to those of us in school buildings, the struggles that many of our students experience shocked a significant number of Americans into believing that our schools were in crisis and needed to be "reformed".  Politicians and educational "entrepreneurs" saw this as an opportunity to make a statement, or a profit, and jumped into the debate over how to make our schools better for all students.  The phrase, "What's best for kids," became a common refrain heard in almost every debate around education.

Moving forward from the 1980's we've seen a wave of "reform" efforts buffeting our public school systems.  The efforts to improve our public schools have dominated public policy debate and have been major parts of political campaigns.  We've seen a wide variety of ideas put forward from voucher programs, to new standards, to new curricula.  Efforts have been made to empower families, empower students, dis-empower educator unions, the list of "reforms" is many.

Yet, when you look at the data and look at the outcomes for students, none of it seems to be working.  Why is it that in a nation with so many resources and so many brilliant minds we just can't seem to create a system, method or program that will educate all of our students?  We jump from reform to reform always in search of the next "magic bullet" that will solve our problems and eliminate the gaps in achievement.  Taxpayers bemoan the huge investment in education that seems to be a "waste" of their money.  Politicians criticize their opponents and look for scapegoats, too often the educators in schools, to gain political power.  The pressure on public schools to meet the needs of all students is incredible.

In the end, I believe that there is one simple reason why our efforts to "reform" our schools and to meet the needs of all of our students don't succeed.  Despite claims to the contrary, education in America has always been more about power and control than about teaching students.  Just look at our nation's educational history.  We've always used education as a tool to promote a specific way of thinking, or as a political tool.  Whether it was used to indoctrinate immigrant children, "Americanize" Native Americans and eliminate language and cultures that were "foreign" to the "majority", or to funnel money to (or away from) different interests, education has been more about power than about learning. 

If we really want to change the conversation around education, if we really want all students to succeed, then we need to realize that education can't be about gaining power and control of those being educated, but must be about empowering our students and our educators.  Unfortunately, most of the, so called, reforms that are being offered are tied directly to some political agenda, or some for profit scheme that ignores the reality that most of our students and educators work and learn in.  

Just look at some of the recent discussions about "fixing" our public education system and you can see just how far from students, educators and learning the conversations are.  Instead of focusing our attention on what our students really need, the debate focuses on policies that do little to impact our most at-risk students directly.  Instead of really trying to address the needs that exist in our schools, too many of the decisions create conditions that actually hamper student learning.  Supporters of public education are reduced to fighting to make sure that voucher and charter schools are held to the same irrelevant and irrational standards as the public schools, or simply trying to defend our public schools from being destroyed by vindictive policies that seek to undermine the political and economic power of professional educators.  Even ideas that sound like they would be positive have been corrupted by outside interests and questionable motives.    
     






What we should be fighting for is a totally different approach to fixing education.  Instead of dissecting good literature, looking for specific criteria and reading historical documents in a sterile context that ignores the stories behind the sources, educators should be teaching all subjects in an integrated and engaging manner.  Instead of cutting back on programs that engage students and expand their skills, we need to put more emphasis on the arts, music, physical education and other "non-core" subjects.  Evidence supports the idea of teaching subjects in this manner, not by teaching skills in isolation.  Yet, we see many of the "reforms" being pushed take us in a more traditional and skill based bearing.  
 

The struggles to define the future of public education in America are vital to our success as a nation.  It is up to us to move the debate in a new direction.  


Compare and Contrast. . .
Most of us remember the essay questions on exams where we were to compare and contrast two books, characters, events, or any number of other things that had been covered in the class we were enrolled in.  While a very common type of question in many classes, they can be a very good critical thinking exercise.  Essentially, to compare and contrast means that we take two different things and look for the similarities and differences between them.  This can be done in any content area and forces students to think carefully about the topics they are analyzing. 

We do this to students all the time in our classrooms, but something happens to many of us when we leave the academic environment.  Too many of us seem to lose our critical thinking skills and instead become entrenched in a dogmatic way of thinking about the world around us.  We accept or reject ideas or opinions based, not on critical thinking, but instead on our entrenched ideas that may or not be supported by information.  As adults we lose our accountability in decision making and become static in our ideas, opinions and problem solving strategies.  We recycle the same "facts" and refuse to consider alternatives to the reality that we exist in.

This lack of critical thinking becomes all too apparent as we continue to engage in bitter debate and conflict on a wide range of issues here in Wisconsin and around the United States.  Sides are drawn, political positions are fortified and groups and individuals on all sides are unwilling to allow for compromise, or even real discussion to occur.

When we do this we ignore the "compare" part of our critical thinking exercise.  To compare different ideas means that we look for similarities between the opposing items.  This can result in some positive building blocks to work with.  After all, we are all citizens of a specific municipality, state and/or nation.  We should have some common interests that could serve to unite us, if we could look beyond the differences that we see too clearly.  We don't have to agree 100% with others, but there should be some common ground to work from.  As human beings who share communities with other humans we need to find these areas of common ground (safety, survival needs, etc.) and build from them. 

"Comparing" can also expose some troubling realities.  When we look at the policies and philosophies of our leadership, there is a striking similarity between their supposedly very different political, social and economic agendas.  Education "reform" provides us with a clear example of this.  The policies of the Bush administration, famous for the debacle of No Child Left Behind, gave way to a more "Progressive", Race to the Top, that essentially continued the policies that have been so harmful to our schools and our students.  In many ways, education "reform" is indicative of the prevailing solutions that are offered at the highest levels of our leadership.  The rhetoric may, or may not, change, but the policies remain strikingly similar.

Economic policy is another place where comparing leads us to believe that the decision makers at the highest levels are very similar in their motivations and their actions.  The wealthiest among us have the most access to power, and are able to move our leaders in directions that clearly benefit a specific segment of the population.

For real, positive change to occur we must look to identify places where these common interests diverge, and different ways of thinking emerge.  This is the "contrast" part of the critical thinking exercise.  If we stay in the "compare" section of our thinking we will remain mired in the same quagmire that we've always existed in.  Comparing requires us to look for differences and to base our decisions on the distinctions between competing ways of thinking.  It means that we don't have to continue our present course, but can work to make a difference in the world we live in.  If enough of us engage in thinking about the contrasts between ideologies we can shape the world that we live in.

This type of thinking can be painful and troubling at times.  It can force us outside of our comfort zones and make us take a stand for what we truly believe in.  It challenges us to look beyond the rhetoric and force our leaders and policy makers to respect the real wishes of the people they lead.  Too many of us are either unwilling to look critically at issues, or operate under the mistaken belief that their opinions don't matter because only the elite have any power.  This combination of ignorance and apathy is deadly, both to democracy, and to the "free-markets" that supposedly drive the American economy.

When we look carefully and analyze our society from a political, social and economic perspective, we can see that there are some real problems with the status quo.  We can also see that there are distinctly different approaches to resolving the problems that we face.  None of these problems are new, or unique to Wisconsin, or America, but we can work to promote creative, Progressive and positive solutions. 

Sometimes we need to have leaders speak up and give voice to our concerns.  Pope Francis has drawn criticism for his views on many issues, but they resonate with many progressive thinkers.  His statements about economics and social justice are particularly poignant.     
“This imbalance is the result of ideologies which defend the absolute autonomy of the marketplace and financial speculation,” Pope Francis wrote. “Consequently, they reject the right of states, charged with vigilance for the common good, to exercise any form of control. A new tyranny is thus born, invisible and often virtual, which unilaterally and relentlessly imposes its own laws and rules.”

“The thirst for power and possessions knows no limits,” Pope Francis wrote. “In this system, which tends to devour everything which stands in the way of increased profits, whatever is fragile, like the environment, is defenseless before the interests of a deified market, which become the only rule.”



There are different approaches to resolving our problems, and nowhere are these differences more stark than between Wisconsin and Minnesota.  




Here in Madison we see a contrast between our measures of success for our African-American citizens and our LGBT citizens.  How is it that a community can score so well for one group and be at the opposite end of the spectrum for others?  How can we work to stay #1 in one area and still improve outcomes for all citizens?  
 

The struggles around Worker's Rights is another example of the need to think critically about issues.  There is a significant portion of the population that refuses to recognize the need for workers to organize and advocate for themselves.  Yet, all the evidence says that without collective action, the "market" simply crushes most individuals.





Here in Wisconsin we are gearing up for another, very visible, conflict around many of these issues.  The elections of 2014 will be won, or lost on the strength of the ability of Progressives to engage the citizenry in critical thinking.  This means finding ways to reach citizens, but also finding ways to influence the leadership that most closely represents our ideals.


Of course we can't forget that in order to effectively compare, contrast and otherwise use our analytical skills to make sound decisions, we need to have accurate information.  This means being careful about who we listen to, where we get our information and otherwise being careful consumers of information we use in our decision making processes.   


Don't forget to spend your money wisely during the holiday season.  Along with your vote, how you spend your money is an important way to express your values.