Showing posts with label Conservative Vs. Progressive. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Conservative Vs. Progressive. Show all posts

Sunday, March 2, 2014

#154 March 2, 2014- Living Up to Our Potential



Land of the ?
Home of the ? . . .
America, like all human endeavors, is a mix of good intentions, successes, unfulfilled potential and failures.  Yet, to admit this is considered to be a mortal sin of unpatriotic and un-American proportions.  We are a nation founded in the midst of a period of social and political upheaval.  Our founding documents reflect a new way of thinking about human societies, and we look at these with a great amount of pride.  The concept of American Exceptionalism is one that demonstrates our pride in our nation, but also is filled with a level of conceit and arrogance that calls into question the very concepts that it supports.  It isn't difficult to find examples of this in the speeches and writing by Americans about America and our self-proclaimed status in the world. 

"I, in my own mind, have always thought of America as a place in the divine scheme of things that was set aside as a promised land. It was set here and the price of admission was very simple: the means of selection was very simple as to how this land should be populated. Any place in the world and any person from those places; any person with the courage, with the desire to tear up their roots, to strive for freedom, to attempt and dare to live in a strange and foreign place, to travel halfway across the world was welcome here."
-Ronald Reagan, Commencement Address at Williams Woods College, June 1952

"...I have been guided by the standard John Winthrop set before his shipmates on the flagship Arbella three hundred and thirty-one years ago, as they, too, faced the task of building a new government on a perilous frontier. 'We must always consider', he said, 'that we shall be as a city upon a hill—the eyes of all people are upon us' . . . "
-John F. Kennedy, Address to the General Court of Massachusetts, Jan. 9, 1961

"America indeed is an exceptional nation, but not because of what it has achieved or accomplished. American is exceptional because it is fundamentally dedicated to the principles of human liberty, grounded on the truths that all men are created equal and endowed with equal rights—permanent truths 'applicable to all men and all times,' as Abraham Lincoln once said. It was because of these principles that rather than ending in tyranny the American Revolution culminated in a constitutional government that has long endured.
America’s principles are responsible for a prosperous and just nation unlike any in the world. "
-Matthew Spalding, What Makes America Exceptional?  The Heritage Foundation
July 4, 2010

Our founding documents, the words of our founders, and the language that has been used to describe and glorify America throughout our history set a high standard for what the United States could and should be.  The question remains, have we lived up to the potential and the ideals that we claim as our own? 

The answers to that question aren't as clear as we are told or would like to believe.  In fact, the results of the "American Experiment", as some Conservatives call it, are mixed and clearly unequal across demographic lines.  The blind patriotism and rhetoric of freedom that is too often expressed in our societal discourse is contradicted by the reality of the circumstances that so many citizens live in.  Whether we look at social, economic or political policies it is clear that we are seeing a combination of ignorance, denial and conscious decisions that serve to undermine the ideals that our nation is supposed to subscribe to. 

We are given false and misleading versions of history that reinforce the misconceptions that allow for modern policies of disenfranchisement and inequality to be implemented. 
      

We see an emphasis placed on specific parts of the Bill of Rights at the expense of other freedoms.  



We use terms like freedom and choice in ways that limit the freedoms and choices available to those who don't fit an extremely narrow vision of what supposedly represents our societal values.  

We put the needs and wants of business and money ahead of people.  


In few places are the divisions between the ideals of our founding documents and the reality of our current self-proclaimed "patriots" more apparent than in our policies around public education.  Where our founders wrote about "liberty and justice for all" and talked about securing "the blessings of liberty for ourselves and our posterity," we now see efforts made to restrict access to vital resources like education.  While blaming public educators, public educator unions, and public schools in general for problems like Achievement Gaps, education "reformers" seek to undermine and exploit the very groups they claim to represent.  



As a nation we've put our trust in politicians and business people to make decisions about our public schools.  The Common Core State Standards are another example of important decisions being made while ignoring the experience and professionalism of educators across America.  Standards aren't necessarily the problem, we need to have some uniform guiding standards in effect.  The problems around the standards are the testing, the standardization/corporatization of curriculum, and the use of the standards as weapons against educators and schools.      



Educators aren't the only important voices that are ignored in our current public educational decision making processes.  Many of our families and students are excluded from important conversations and instead are represented by those who claim to speak for them.   



Yet, many of these "reformers" clearly have another agenda and different priorities, other than those of the students and families they claim to represent.  



In these troubling times it is easy to lose hope and feel like we are engaged in a losing battle to defend our Progressive values against extreme Conservatism, and against the self-defined Liberals who are often just as damaging in their words and actions.  We can spend a significant amount of time bemoaning our current climate and conditions, but this is counterproductive and ineffective.  In the end it is the people and our actions in the present day, not the words of our predecessors that make our nation what it is, and shape its future.  We can look to the past for inspiration.

"I like to see a man proud of the place in which he lives.  I like to see a man live so that his place will be proud of him." 

-Attributed to Abraham Lincoln

History will not judge our endeavors—and a government cannot be selected—merely on the basis of color or creed or even party affiliation. Neither will competence and loyalty and stature, while essential to the utmost, suffice in times such as these. For of those to whom much is given, much is required . . . "
 -John F. Kennedy, Address to the General Court of Massachusetts, Jan. 9, 1961

We can see evidence of the struggle and positive efforts all around us.  Americans are becoming more aware of the need to support labor and worker's rights.  


In education there is a renewed sense of purpose and a number of efforts being made across the country to implement real reform and to push back against the privatization of our public schools.  



Information about the harmful effects of excessive standardized testing and the standardization of curriculum is spreading.  



Every once in a while we see a glimmer of hope that those  at the highest levels of government may recognize the need for different voices to be heard.  


More importantly, the supporters of public education across our nation are realizing that it is up to us to defend our public schools.  We are standing up for ourselves, our students and our communities and working to make a difference at the local level and in individual classrooms and schools.  Together we can forge powerful connections that will help spread accurate information about education, while working to support those who seek to truly improve the opportunities for all students in our public schools.    


The Good, The Bad and
The Ugly. . .
The Good . . . Unity, strength and community go a long way in our struggle.



The Bad . . . Scary.


The Ugly . . . Terrifying.

Sunday, January 26, 2014

#149 January 26, 2014- Public Ed., Technology and Social Justice



Vouching for Public Schools. . .
We are constantly being showered with rhetoric that tells us our public schools are failing, that a significant number of our educators are either incompetent, unmotivated or both, and that we need to make drastic changes in the system in order to increase the equity in educational opportunities for all students.  Yet, the attacks are grounded in some false assumptions, half-truths and a legacy of efforts designed to undermine our public education systems across the nation.

Neither political party and very few interest groups have really stepped up to defend our public schools, despite the fact that these schools are the only place where services for students of all needs and demographics are mandated.  Instead, we have seen a call for re-segregating our schools and recreating a separate and unequal system that is not only unfair, but also unconstitutional.  Our public schools have been consistently maligned, underfunded and overregulated by those who claim to be acting "for the children." 


Yet, when funded and supported we have seen achievement gaps closed by our schools, and it is only in the last 25 years, as cuts to funding and new mandates were implemented, that we have seen this progress halted.  Here in Wisconsin we've seen cuts to education that are unprecedented in scale, and the efforts to demean the efforts of public educators intensified.  Data about our schools are twisted, and "reform" rhetoric has become the norm in discourse about public education.       
   



We are seeing pushback from supporters of public education.  A great example comes from those fighting against the efforts to promote legislation creating a special needs voucher (re-titled scholarship) program.




Tech, Trust,  Obstruction
and Advocacy . . .
Technology can be a valuable tool in our daily lives, and plays an important role in the education of our students as well.  The Madison school district recently unveiled an ambitious plan to improve access to technology for students in the district.    



Response to the plan was mixed, and there were strong opinions raised on all sides of the issue.  This topic has become a source of some controversy and intense feelings with a few unnecessary snide comments thrown in.    
Please take some time to look at the plan. If you have thoughts, questions, recommendations or even a reaction to share, we’d love to hear from you. Fire up the digital device of your choice, and send us an email at board@madison.k12.wi.us. If you think we’re making a mistake by proposing to race headlong into this technology thing, let us know that as well. But you might want to deliver that message via the Postal Service.


host.madison.com

While you should take time to read the plan itself, and formulate your own opinions, I want to take the time to expand on the position of those "opposed" to the plan. 

First, to identify us as opposed to the technology plan is inaccurate.  We support a plan to get technology in to our schools and in to the hands of our students.  Technology is a huge expense and these are tough financial times for schools.  To add technology, or any other initiative without careful planning and open, honest dialog would be a huge mistake and one that would likely cause more harm than benefit for our students.  The opposition arises not from an anti-technology viewpoint, but from an effort to insure wise implementation, to address existing needs, and to protect things that are of value from funding cuts. 

I would hope that in a district committed to education of all students, that opinions from the community would be a valued part of the discussion.  To imply that those who question the plan are out of touch with the modern world, as Board President Hughes does in his article on the MMSD website, does little to build support for the plan, or to foster open communication around this, or any, issue.

That leads directly to the issue of the speed with which supporters  are moving forward with the plan.  While they are making the argument that the tech plan has been a topic of discussion for months, many in the district have only become aware of the details in the past week or so.  Educators and students in the district have suffered from the quick implementation of district wide initiatives that have had mixed results in recent years.  The adoption of a district wide reading program for elementary students in the recent past is an example of this type of action.  One of our strengths as a district is the well educated and highly involved community that our schools are embedded in.  Through discussion and public input we will see new ideas come forth, and a stronger plan developed.

This isn't to say that we need to study, discuss and reformulate technology plans over the course of years, but rather that opening the discussion to a wider audience, including educators at a variety of buildings, will give us better results in the long run.  In the week or so since the plan was introduced we have seen input given, and modifications made in the plan.  Clearly there is an opportunity here to develop a positive and sustainable vehicle to get technology in to MMSD schools.  We appreciate the willingness of administration to listen to concerns, and hope that more opportunities will be given before a final plan is passed.               

The question that Tech Plan supporters have is, why would anyone resist improving the technology available to MMSD students?  After all, technology isn't going away and our district has not consistently kept up with the latest innovations and advances available.  Once again I remind you that those voicing concerns about the plan are not opposed to technology, nor are we simply obstructionists who want to criticize any new initiative.  In order to support a Tech Plan, or any initiative, I feel that a few basic issues must be addressed.

1- It must not take away from existing or new programs that build human supports for our students, families and community.  Education is a labor intensive endeavor and we need as many people as possible actively involved in the process.  Things like Ready, Set, Goal conferences, school staff in the most at-risk communities and enough staff to insure the diverse needs of all learners are met need to take precedence over any technology or materials that are purchased. 
While we are being assured that the Tech Plan won't restrict spending on these needs, it is difficult to believe that we will not see technology pitted against human resources at some time in the not so distant future. 

2- It must build on the strengths that exist in our schools, and fill a genuine need in a meaningful way.  There are many innovative ways that MMSD staff is using technology right now, and we should build off of these programs.  If we simply put devices in our schools we will not get the maximum benefit from our investment.  Putting decision making about technology at the school level can insure that we tailor purchases to the needs of a building and that funds are used in the best manner possible. 

3- It must be sustainable and supportable.  Too often we see our current technology failing us for a variety of reasons, and the idea that adding more will somehow improve things seems illogical.  There will be significant costs involved in educating educators to use technology most effectively, and to maintain the devices in buildings.  The best plans are often simple and develop over time, once again building on the strengths in each school around the district.

Unfortunately, there is also a history here of initiatives being rolled out to great fanfare, and then abandoned just as quickly.  It is unfair, and short sighted to oppose initiatives solely for this reason, but also very human to feel apprehension when a huge plan like this is unveiled.  Those anxieties are increased when a plan is accelerated through the system, and when those in favor of it speak in stark terms of "your either with us, or against us."  I hope that we can continue the dialog and emerge with a plan that will feature the best possible solutions to some very challenging problems.      

I invite everyone to come to the regular Board of Education meeting on Monday, January 27th @ 6PM in the McDaniels Auditorium at the Doyle Building to hear more about the plan.  Several SCAPE members will be offering their ideas, and we hope to hear from others in the community as well.  

State of My State. . .
"I have almost reached the regrettable conclusion that the Negro's great stumbling block in his stride toward freedom is […] the white moderate, who is more devoted to 'order' than to justice; who prefers a negative peace which is the absence of tension to a positive peace which is the presence of justice."  These words come from Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.'s "Letter from a Birmingham Jail" and ring true through the years.  I would argue that we are facing conditions that are returning us to an America where access to opportunity and justice are becoming more restricted, and that we are seeing issues of injustice becoming more widespread with every passing day.  While visibly true for citizens of different races, all of us are feeling the effects of policies designed to divide and conquer us.  Whatever your demographic identity, it is becoming clear that we are facing a concerted effort to return American society to a time in history where phrases like, "All men" meant some men, and "The general welfare" referred to a select few.      

The idea that Dr. King espouses about "the white moderate" can be expanded to include anyone of any demographic who is satisfied with the current status quo that exists in our state and our nation.  We are hearing a lot about "freedom", "opportunity" and "equality", but the words are ringing hollow when we see the reality that so many of our fellow citizens are experiencing.  Too many of us are simply willing to sit on the sidelines and allow those who are in power manipulate our system and speak for us. 

We need to increase the tension in our society in a positive way.  This means speaking up for what we believe in and not accepting the word of social, political and economic leaders as truth simply because it was uttered by someone with credentials.  We need to make sure that we stay informed and involved and use whatever methods available to make our voices heard in the debates that currently occupy our attention.  We also need to make sure that we are aware of future struggles looming on the horizon. 

Dr. King was a champion for Civil Rights, which included rights for all people.  He was a voice for labor, a voice against violence and a voice for equality for all.  His message and legacy, which we honored on Monday, is one that we need to make sure is heard throughout the year, and applied to all situations.  It is interesting to see how Dr. King's memory is juxtaposed with the message that was delivered by Scott Walker on Wednesday.  Walker used some of the same words like "opportunity" and spoke of putting "power back in to the hands of the people."  However, the truth behind these words is not the truth that Dr. King spoke about. 



It is up to us to reject order unless it leads to justice, and to create the tension that is necessary to lead our state down the path towards opportunity and justice for all.  We must refuse to allow empty words and promises to replace the collective actions that promote widespread equality and positive relationships between citizens of many different demographics.  We can't forget that all the talk of budget surpluses and tax refunds are part of an agenda that focuses on building economic success for a few on the backs of the many.  As George Washington said, "Truth will ultimately prevail where there is pains taken to bring it to light." 
 





The Good, The Bad
and The Ugly. . .
The Good . . .  A victory for labor!!



The Bad . . .  Another federal court case that could change things drastically for unions around America.  Meanwhile, Wisconsin unions await our Supreme Court's ruling on MTI's case against Act 10.  


The Ugly . . .  We know that there are inequities in the distribution of wealth, but this is startling.



Meanwhile, most of us are working harder, and losing ground.  

Sunday, December 1, 2013

#141 December 1, 2013- Failed Potential and Critical Thinking



What's Best for Kids. . .
America is a nation with virtually unlimited potential.  As a society we are able to accomplish great things and have a history of tremendous achievements in almost every aspect of human activity.  Yet, despite this potential and history of achievement, there are still some areas where widespread success has proved incredibly elusive.  One of the most significant of these is our inability to address issues of equality and opportunity for all citizens.  This failure has been a consistent feature of our society from the very beginning, but is has been magnified in recent years beginning with the "War on Poverty" and continuing to the huge disparity in wealth in current American society. 

These gaps in opportunity and achievement are clearly on display in our educational system.  We have a system that is one of the best in the world for some students, and one that struggles to match these successes for many others.  Our Achievement Gaps in schools, mirror the gaps that exist in our society in terms of income and access to power. 


For all of its flaws, one positive that No Child Left Behind accomplished was to shine a light on these gaps in our schools.  While it didn't come as a surprise to those of us in school buildings, the struggles that many of our students experience shocked a significant number of Americans into believing that our schools were in crisis and needed to be "reformed".  Politicians and educational "entrepreneurs" saw this as an opportunity to make a statement, or a profit, and jumped into the debate over how to make our schools better for all students.  The phrase, "What's best for kids," became a common refrain heard in almost every debate around education.

Moving forward from the 1980's we've seen a wave of "reform" efforts buffeting our public school systems.  The efforts to improve our public schools have dominated public policy debate and have been major parts of political campaigns.  We've seen a wide variety of ideas put forward from voucher programs, to new standards, to new curricula.  Efforts have been made to empower families, empower students, dis-empower educator unions, the list of "reforms" is many.

Yet, when you look at the data and look at the outcomes for students, none of it seems to be working.  Why is it that in a nation with so many resources and so many brilliant minds we just can't seem to create a system, method or program that will educate all of our students?  We jump from reform to reform always in search of the next "magic bullet" that will solve our problems and eliminate the gaps in achievement.  Taxpayers bemoan the huge investment in education that seems to be a "waste" of their money.  Politicians criticize their opponents and look for scapegoats, too often the educators in schools, to gain political power.  The pressure on public schools to meet the needs of all students is incredible.

In the end, I believe that there is one simple reason why our efforts to "reform" our schools and to meet the needs of all of our students don't succeed.  Despite claims to the contrary, education in America has always been more about power and control than about teaching students.  Just look at our nation's educational history.  We've always used education as a tool to promote a specific way of thinking, or as a political tool.  Whether it was used to indoctrinate immigrant children, "Americanize" Native Americans and eliminate language and cultures that were "foreign" to the "majority", or to funnel money to (or away from) different interests, education has been more about power than about learning. 

If we really want to change the conversation around education, if we really want all students to succeed, then we need to realize that education can't be about gaining power and control of those being educated, but must be about empowering our students and our educators.  Unfortunately, most of the, so called, reforms that are being offered are tied directly to some political agenda, or some for profit scheme that ignores the reality that most of our students and educators work and learn in.  

Just look at some of the recent discussions about "fixing" our public education system and you can see just how far from students, educators and learning the conversations are.  Instead of focusing our attention on what our students really need, the debate focuses on policies that do little to impact our most at-risk students directly.  Instead of really trying to address the needs that exist in our schools, too many of the decisions create conditions that actually hamper student learning.  Supporters of public education are reduced to fighting to make sure that voucher and charter schools are held to the same irrelevant and irrational standards as the public schools, or simply trying to defend our public schools from being destroyed by vindictive policies that seek to undermine the political and economic power of professional educators.  Even ideas that sound like they would be positive have been corrupted by outside interests and questionable motives.    
     






What we should be fighting for is a totally different approach to fixing education.  Instead of dissecting good literature, looking for specific criteria and reading historical documents in a sterile context that ignores the stories behind the sources, educators should be teaching all subjects in an integrated and engaging manner.  Instead of cutting back on programs that engage students and expand their skills, we need to put more emphasis on the arts, music, physical education and other "non-core" subjects.  Evidence supports the idea of teaching subjects in this manner, not by teaching skills in isolation.  Yet, we see many of the "reforms" being pushed take us in a more traditional and skill based bearing.  
 

The struggles to define the future of public education in America are vital to our success as a nation.  It is up to us to move the debate in a new direction.  


Compare and Contrast. . .
Most of us remember the essay questions on exams where we were to compare and contrast two books, characters, events, or any number of other things that had been covered in the class we were enrolled in.  While a very common type of question in many classes, they can be a very good critical thinking exercise.  Essentially, to compare and contrast means that we take two different things and look for the similarities and differences between them.  This can be done in any content area and forces students to think carefully about the topics they are analyzing. 

We do this to students all the time in our classrooms, but something happens to many of us when we leave the academic environment.  Too many of us seem to lose our critical thinking skills and instead become entrenched in a dogmatic way of thinking about the world around us.  We accept or reject ideas or opinions based, not on critical thinking, but instead on our entrenched ideas that may or not be supported by information.  As adults we lose our accountability in decision making and become static in our ideas, opinions and problem solving strategies.  We recycle the same "facts" and refuse to consider alternatives to the reality that we exist in.

This lack of critical thinking becomes all too apparent as we continue to engage in bitter debate and conflict on a wide range of issues here in Wisconsin and around the United States.  Sides are drawn, political positions are fortified and groups and individuals on all sides are unwilling to allow for compromise, or even real discussion to occur.

When we do this we ignore the "compare" part of our critical thinking exercise.  To compare different ideas means that we look for similarities between the opposing items.  This can result in some positive building blocks to work with.  After all, we are all citizens of a specific municipality, state and/or nation.  We should have some common interests that could serve to unite us, if we could look beyond the differences that we see too clearly.  We don't have to agree 100% with others, but there should be some common ground to work from.  As human beings who share communities with other humans we need to find these areas of common ground (safety, survival needs, etc.) and build from them. 

"Comparing" can also expose some troubling realities.  When we look at the policies and philosophies of our leadership, there is a striking similarity between their supposedly very different political, social and economic agendas.  Education "reform" provides us with a clear example of this.  The policies of the Bush administration, famous for the debacle of No Child Left Behind, gave way to a more "Progressive", Race to the Top, that essentially continued the policies that have been so harmful to our schools and our students.  In many ways, education "reform" is indicative of the prevailing solutions that are offered at the highest levels of our leadership.  The rhetoric may, or may not, change, but the policies remain strikingly similar.

Economic policy is another place where comparing leads us to believe that the decision makers at the highest levels are very similar in their motivations and their actions.  The wealthiest among us have the most access to power, and are able to move our leaders in directions that clearly benefit a specific segment of the population.

For real, positive change to occur we must look to identify places where these common interests diverge, and different ways of thinking emerge.  This is the "contrast" part of the critical thinking exercise.  If we stay in the "compare" section of our thinking we will remain mired in the same quagmire that we've always existed in.  Comparing requires us to look for differences and to base our decisions on the distinctions between competing ways of thinking.  It means that we don't have to continue our present course, but can work to make a difference in the world we live in.  If enough of us engage in thinking about the contrasts between ideologies we can shape the world that we live in.

This type of thinking can be painful and troubling at times.  It can force us outside of our comfort zones and make us take a stand for what we truly believe in.  It challenges us to look beyond the rhetoric and force our leaders and policy makers to respect the real wishes of the people they lead.  Too many of us are either unwilling to look critically at issues, or operate under the mistaken belief that their opinions don't matter because only the elite have any power.  This combination of ignorance and apathy is deadly, both to democracy, and to the "free-markets" that supposedly drive the American economy.

When we look carefully and analyze our society from a political, social and economic perspective, we can see that there are some real problems with the status quo.  We can also see that there are distinctly different approaches to resolving the problems that we face.  None of these problems are new, or unique to Wisconsin, or America, but we can work to promote creative, Progressive and positive solutions. 

Sometimes we need to have leaders speak up and give voice to our concerns.  Pope Francis has drawn criticism for his views on many issues, but they resonate with many progressive thinkers.  His statements about economics and social justice are particularly poignant.     
“This imbalance is the result of ideologies which defend the absolute autonomy of the marketplace and financial speculation,” Pope Francis wrote. “Consequently, they reject the right of states, charged with vigilance for the common good, to exercise any form of control. A new tyranny is thus born, invisible and often virtual, which unilaterally and relentlessly imposes its own laws and rules.”

“The thirst for power and possessions knows no limits,” Pope Francis wrote. “In this system, which tends to devour everything which stands in the way of increased profits, whatever is fragile, like the environment, is defenseless before the interests of a deified market, which become the only rule.”



There are different approaches to resolving our problems, and nowhere are these differences more stark than between Wisconsin and Minnesota.  




Here in Madison we see a contrast between our measures of success for our African-American citizens and our LGBT citizens.  How is it that a community can score so well for one group and be at the opposite end of the spectrum for others?  How can we work to stay #1 in one area and still improve outcomes for all citizens?  
 

The struggles around Worker's Rights is another example of the need to think critically about issues.  There is a significant portion of the population that refuses to recognize the need for workers to organize and advocate for themselves.  Yet, all the evidence says that without collective action, the "market" simply crushes most individuals.





Here in Wisconsin we are gearing up for another, very visible, conflict around many of these issues.  The elections of 2014 will be won, or lost on the strength of the ability of Progressives to engage the citizenry in critical thinking.  This means finding ways to reach citizens, but also finding ways to influence the leadership that most closely represents our ideals.


Of course we can't forget that in order to effectively compare, contrast and otherwise use our analytical skills to make sound decisions, we need to have accurate information.  This means being careful about who we listen to, where we get our information and otherwise being careful consumers of information we use in our decision making processes.   


Don't forget to spend your money wisely during the holiday season.  Along with your vote, how you spend your money is an important way to express your values.